German Architect Behind NYC’s Skyscrapers | Passport
The Immigrant Architect Whose Passport Outlasted His Skyscrapers
Paul Gmelin left Ulm, Germany in the late nineteenth century and ended up with his name on some of the buildings that defined New York’s early skyline. I’ve spent years tracking down passports that connect ordinary travel documents to extraordinary lives, and Gmelin’s 1930 U.S. passport is one of my favorites precisely because the paper trail lines up so neatly with the architectural record.


Gmelin was born in 1858 in Ulm. He started his American career as a draftsman for Bridge Builders Magazine, and it was there that the late Charles McKim asked him to prepare a perspective drawing of the Boston Public Library. That commission apparently marked him as a skilled designer, because he went on to work consecutively for several major New York architectural firms, including Babb, Cook & Willard, Cyrus Eidlitz, and Eidlitz & MacKenzie. At the latter firm, he worked on the plans for the New York Times Building and was credited with much of the original design work.
How a German Immigrant Ended Up Naming a Manhattan Firm
Gmelin’s name sits in the title of a prestigious New York firm because he was made partner during a pivotal restructuring in 1910. The parent company traced its heritage back to Cyrus L.W. Eidlitz, who founded it in New York City in 1885. Andrew C. McKenzie joined as partner in 1900, and when Eidlitz left in 1910, Stephen Francis Voorhees (1878 to 1965) and Paul Gmelin stepped in to fill the gap. Gmelin began his own professional practice that same year, in partnership with MacKenzie and Voorhees, and the arrangement held for sixteen years.

When MacKenzie died in 1926, Ralph Walker, who had already been with the firm for several years, took his place as partner, and the firm became Voorhees, Gmelin, and Walker. During this period, Gmelin was identified with the design of several notable structures: the New York Telephone Building in Albany (1913), the Walter Lispenard Building in New York (1914), and the Brooklyn Municipal Building (1924), which cost $5,800,000 to complete and still houses city offices, including the City Clerk, at the southwest corner of Joralemon and Court Streets in Brooklyn.
The firm kept evolving after Gmelin’s era. In 1938 it became Voorhees, Walker, Foley, and Smith, then Voorhees, Walker, Smith, and Smith in 1955. Voorhees stayed on as senior partner until January 1959, when he moved into a consulting role. After Perry Coke Smith retired in 1968, the name changed again to Haines Lundberg Waehler, known today as HLW. The firm built a reputation for its Art Deco work, a style that came to define much of the era’s skyline. Gmelin himself died in 1937 at his home in Cranford, New Jersey, at age seventy-nine.
What Gmelin’s Passport Actually Records
Gmelin’s 1930 U.S. passport documents a European trip that shadows the professional life the architectural record already describes. It’s a red standard U.S. passport with 32 pages, issued on 6 June 1930 to Paul, his wife Rosa, and their son Stephen. Page six carries an American Consulate stamp from Stuttgart, entered by Vice Consul Shiras Morris Jr., where Stephen was excluded from the document in 1932. Page seven holds a British double visa from 1930, from when Stephen was still included. Page eight has a Swiss border stamp, and page nine carries a German visa, also from 1930.

In October 1931, the passport was renewed until 1932 at the American Consulate in Stuttgart, this time by Vice Consul George C. Minor. A little biographical digging on Minor turns up an interesting career arc of his own: born in Charleston, Kanawha County, West Virginia, he served as U.S. Vice Consul in Tirana from roughly 1927 to 1929, Stuttgart in 1931 to 1932, Moscow from 1934 to 1938, Toronto in 1940, and Ottawa from 1940 to 1943. Page eleven of Gmelin’s passport shows a German visa dated August 1931, and pages 31 and 32 carry border stamps from Italy and Switzerland, the last dated 16 April 1932, marking his exit from Italy. The document survives in excellent condition, a solid physical record of one immigrant architect’s travels back to the country he’d left decades earlier.
Why One Passport Tells a Much Bigger Immigration Story
Gmelin’s document is a fitting artifact for the much larger story of Germans building a new nation in America. Around 50 million German Americans lived in the United States as of the 2010 census, making German the largest self-reported ancestry group in the country and putting them ahead of Irish, African, English, Mexican, and Italian Americans, at around 17 percent of the population as of 2009. Not a bad legacy for a colony that started with just thirteen families from Krefeld.
Germans first set foot in what’s now the United States as early as 1608, but the real beginning of organized German settlement came in 1683, when a group of religious dissidents approached Francis Daniel Pastorius in Frankfurt am Main. Pastorius, a trained lawyer working as an agent for the German Society, a consortium of German land investors, negotiated the purchase of 5,700 acres in Pennsylvania from William Penn, the Englishman who’d founded the colony a few years earlier. That land became Germantown.
Worth remembering here: the Germany those settlers left didn’t exist yet as a unified country. That wouldn’t happen until 1871. In 1683 they were emigrating from separate German-speaking states loosely governed under the Catholic Holy Roman Empire, and the pressure to leave had been building since Martin Luther posted his ninety-five theses in Wittenberg in 1517, urging people to follow scripture over papal authority. The Thirty Years’ War, one of the most destructive conflicts in European history, broke out in 1618, and it was against that backdrop that many Germans decided the New World was worth the risk. You can read more on the wider migration story here.
Tom Topol | Passport Historian & Author
Featured by BBC, CNN, Financial Times and Newsweek. Awarded by the U.S. Department of State
Contact | Press & Media | Books | Explore 1000+ Expert Articles

